Red Wagon Growth Marketing Agency


Attract and Retain Policyholders with Insurance Marketing from a Top Digital Marketing Agency

Digital technology has changed the way consumers shop for and choose an insurance provider: 75% of shoppers obtain quotes and research insurance via the web, and for millennials, communicating with agents solely online is the norm.
To effectively attract and retain more policyholders in today’s digital economy, you need to connect with shoppers in all the places they spend their time online: in the search engines, on social media, in their email inboxes, and on their mobile devices. Scroll down to see the digital marketing services you need to generate more referrals, convert more new policyholders, and provide better value to your existing customers.
Learn more about our digital marketing services for insurance agents below, or if you’re ready to start getting more leads contact us here >>
Your insurance marketing plan should start and end online because that’s where the majority of your key interactions with policyholders take place. They start their search for insurance with a search engine (like Google), they’ll judge your credibility based on your website presence and online reviews, they expect to be able to manage their account online, and they expect personalized communication.
Our digital marketing packages cover all these bases by incorporating the following services:

Digital Competitive Analysis

This is the first step you should take when planning any digital marketing strategy. A thorough competitive analysis will identify your agency’s Strengths, Weaknesses, Threats, and Opportunities from a digital marketing perspective. The report includes actionable insights to help you close any gaps and get ahead of your competition.


Content Marketing

Attract, acquire, and engage existing and potential policyholders through the creation and distribution of relevant and valuable content, including landing pages, insurance blog posts, e-books, email newsletters, white papers, and more (written by our professional, US-based writers).


Email Marketing Campaigns

Looking for a cost-effective way to grow your insurance agency? Catch new policyholders and get more referrals from existing ones with email marketing. It’s one of the most effective forms of insurance marketing, and for every $1 spent, $44 is made in return.

Facebook Advertising Campaigns

68% of Americans are on Facebook, and Facebook is one social media advertising channel that insurance agents find the most effective. We are absolute Facebook advertising experts and can work through Facebook’s restrictions to create low-cost, high-reward campaigns to generate referrals and create life-long customers.

Conversion Rate Optimization

Do you know how well your website is converting leads into lifelong policyholders? Our conversion rate experts will implement tests to improve your visit-to-lead conversion rates. We’ve helped companies in many B2B industries double, triple, and even quadruple their website conversion rates.


Website Design & Development

Your website is frequently the first interaction policyholders have with your company, and 48% of people cited a website’s design as the number one factor in deciding the credibility of the company. Our insurance website design agency specializes in compliant, mobile-friendly websites that have high conversion rates.

LinkedIn Advertising Campaigns

Looking for commercial insurance marketing ideas? LinkedIn is the perfect platform. LinkedIn’s B2B audience has 2x the buying power of the average web audience, and four out of five LinkedIn members drive business decisions. Connect with them through LinkedIn advertising. Learn more about this incredibly targeted way to put your message in front of key decision makers today!

Pay Per Click (PPC)

Get in front of customers at the moment they need you with PPC search ads—97% of online experiences begin with a search engine, but 41% of clicks go to the top 3 paid ads on the search results page. Pay per click is a great way to drive more (qualified) visitors to your website and get more leads—FAST!


Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

Want to get more earned traffic, leads, and new clients? Start where 97% of online experiences start—with search engines. Grow your long-term authority and get more qualified website traffic, leads, and sales with search engine optimization (SEO).

Social Media Marketing

If you want to connect with customers in the place they spend the most time, you need social media marketing for insurance agents—81% of US adults have at least one social media profile and 30% of all time spent online is spent on social media sites. Start your social media marketing campaigns—including Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Instagram, and more—today.


Video Marketing Services

A video is 50 times more likely to rank organically in the search results than text pages, and by 2019, video will account for 80% of global internet traffic and 85% of online traffic in the US. What are you waiting for? Enhance your website, differentiate your brand, and get more leads with online videos!

Review Us Now

Referrals are the best sources for new policyholders, and if you don’t have them, you’re losing clients to competitors. Review Us Now is our proprietary software that helps you to get more reviews on your website and external sites in three simple steps. Ask for your free demo today!


Smart Selling & Lead Recovery

In an industry where customer relationships are key, you need a customer service team that can convert and upsell customers over the phone. We know how to harness the power of call monitoring to vastly improve customer service experiences and greatly increase your return on marketing investments. Our team can help your company extract the most value possible from every phone call.

Branding and Creative Services

No matter your firm’s size or location, a strong, effective, and cohesive brand strategy and design help to convey your company’s quality, credibility, value, and experience. When it comes to marketing your products and services, those that have a strong brand hold an enormous competitive advantage.

Strategy and Analytics Consulting

Does your company have an in-house marketing team but still feel lacking in the mastery of digital marketing and SEO? Whether you’re the marketing manager at an enterprise-level auto insurance company or own a small life insurance practice, strategy and analytics consulting may provide the marketing tools you need!

Local SEO

If you’re a local insurance agency, local SEO is a necessity. Why? Because 97% of consumers go online to find local services. How do you connect with them? With local search engine optimization (SEO). Your customers are searching for your business—let Red Wagon help them find you..

Our Online Insurance Marketing Services in More Detail

Website Design for Insurance Brokers and Agencies

In an age where the majority of policyholders prefer to communicate with insurance agents online, your website isn’t a brochure; it’s a 24/7 concierge, advisor, and virtual sales rep. You only have seconds to make a first impression, so your website’s messaging needs to immediately connect with shoppers. Your website also needs to be fast, secure, mobile-friendly, and most importantly, your website must be coded in a way that makes it easy for the search engines’ software to find, crawl, and index your website.
Our insurance marketing company specializes in coding websites and landing pages that are not only visually appealing but also are highly optimized for search engines—allowing your company to get more traffic, leads, and sales from the internet.

Insurance SEO and Content Marketing


Consumers are not only looking for your services, but they’re also looking for answers to all their insurance questions, which means you need to show up in the top of the organic search results for queries like “Should I buy life insurance?” and “How much auto insurance do I need?” To rank well organically, you must establish and promote yourself as the insurance authority in your market. Ranking well on Google, Bing, and Yahoo requires three things:
  1. First, your website needs to be fast, secure, and mobile-friendly. More than 40% of online users will hit the “back” button if a website takes longer than three seconds to load. Not only that, but search engines favor websites that are fast, secure (HTTPS vs. HTTP), and mobile-friendly.

  2. Second, you need a data-driven content strategy with unique, relevant, high-quality content your customers crave. Google ranks web pages individually, not websites as a whole. Our content marketing team never runs out of creative insurance marketing ideas and has extensive experience writing online content (including insurance blogs, postcards, landing pages, press releases, e-mail newsletters, E-books, and more) specifically for insurance companies—so you won’t have to write a thing.

  3. Third, you need to promote your site to other relevant and authoritative websites and get them to link to, reference, and cite you as an authority. Unlike other SEO companies, you’ll never have to worry about us building spammy links that will get you penalized by Google!


While millennials prefer to look for insurance online, Baby Boomers still like that face-to-face interaction—which means you need to show up in local listings when someone searches for your services. These local listings often appear before the organic listings, leading to better click-through rates for your company from potential customers.
As an award-winning SEO company, we understand that the more listings you have on the first page of search results—including local listings, organic listings, and paid listings—the better. Our local SEO services can increase your visibility for geographically related searches.


When it comes to insurance ads, we always recommend investing in both pay per click (PPC) and SEO services. When you hire Red Wagon for PPC management, we handle it all—from keyword discovery to bid management; from ad copy creation to ad split testing; from pay per click call tracking to landing page optimization; we take care of everything and report the results to you monthly.
Investing in PPC, content marketing, and SEO, as well as local SEO, is the most effective way to get more leads and sales from the web as well as maximize your company’s online real estate. When you have a paid listing, local listing, and organic listing for a given search query, you greatly reduce the chance of someone clicking on one of your competitor’s links!

Determine Your True Marketing ROI with Advanced Analytics and Tracking

Today’s policyholders expect personalized experiences and products, and you can give them what they want by taking advantage of advanced analytics. By analyzing key points of data, we can help you provide more personalized shopping experiences as well as offer customers real-time, customized product recommendations. We accurately measure and track each and every insurance advertising campaign (from pay per click to SEO to email newsletters and more) to find out which advertising and marketing strategies work and which should be changed or eliminated
But don’t worry! You won’t receive loads of reports or spreadsheets to analyze! We understand that you’re busy running your business and you simply don’t have time for that. That’s why we’ll also analyze your data and give you actionable recommendations to measurably improve your performance.

At Red Wagon, our marketing analytics services include:

Accurate measuring and tracking is truly the first step in marketing online so you can quantify your marketing investments.

Why Select Red Wagon Over Other Insurance Marketing Agencies?

We’ve helped insurance brokers and agencies all over the USA and North America—and we can help yours, too.
At Red Wagon, we try and let our clients speak for us. Take a look at our internet marketing reviews from current and former clients to hear straight from them why we are the best internet marketing company for your needs. Everything we do comes from the perspective of a business owner, and we treat your company like our own. What does that mean?
  • You won’t be handcuffed to long-term contracts. We won’t handcuff you for a specific amount of time. Ever. While we encourage you to give your campaigns at least three to six months to fully ramp up, you are free to leave and take your assets with you at any time.

  • You’ll own all your deliverables, including your website. Some marketing firms for insurance agents offer “free” websites with their services or offer websites hosted on their “proprietary platform.” These are red flags that indicate you’re about to be handcuffed into an unfavorable contract. You can learn more about website ownership clauses here >>

  • You’ll optimize your marketing costs. Everything we do is tracked with advanced analytics so we can continually optimize your campaigns. This means you spend less and get more.

  • You get a dedicated account manager to be your guide, as well as a full support team that includes an analyst, a web designer/developer, PPC ad manager, and professional, USA-based insurance services copywriter.

  • You get the peace of mind that we have your back. Digital marketing is a long-term investment, which is why we believe in building partnerships, not acquiring clients. You can rest assured your dedicated account manager will be there for all of your needs and will over-deliver on results.
  • You get detailed monthly reports (you can actually understand) that tie your digital marketing services to your bottom line.

Choose Insurance Marketing Services from the Top Agency Today

Contact us today for a free consultation. Tell us about your situation and we’ll provide you with candid recommendations for online marketing services. Click on the services above to learn more, read our online marketing case studies detailing actual results we’ve produced for business just like yours, or pick up the phone and call us today We’re here for all your insurance or annuity marketing services.